A delivery truck bearing the logo "Smith Transport, Inc." struck a cyclist. Within the one-year limitations period, the cyclist sued "Smith Moving & Storage, Inc." in federal court, mistakenly believing that company operated the truck. The truck's actual owner, Smith Transport, Inc., is a separate corporation.
It received notice of the suit within 90 days after the complaint was filed and knew that, but for the cyclist's mistake, it would have been named. After the limitations period expired, the cyclist moved to amend to substitute Smith Transport, Inc. as the defendant.
Will the amendment relate back to the original complaint?
Pick a letter: the verdict follows the last option, and the reasoning under all four opens.
-
Reasoning for A
Why A is right. Rule 15(c)(1)(C) lets a change of party relate back when the new party, within the Rule 4(m) period, had notice and knew or should have known it would have been named but for a mistake about identity; Smith Transport had both. -
Reasoning for B
Why not B. Arising from the same occurrence is only the first condition; a new defendant also needs timely notice and knowledge of the mistake, so nothing about relation back is automatic. -
Reasoning for C
Why not C. Saving a timely claim against the right party after the period expires is the very purpose of relation back, so the expiration of the limitations period is not a bar in itself. -
Reasoning for D
Why not D. Notice plus a claim from the same occurrence would fall short without more, but Smith Transport also knew it was the intended defendant, so the missing knowledge element is present.